Mistohay Lake Fishing Reports & Lake Feedback

Current Rating:

Average of 19 ratings as of Oct. 25, 2018

Latest Comments:

Star Star Star Star Star

by Buck9 on Oct. 25, 2018

Out on the weekend. Walleye were finicky but managed to catch a few little guys. All went back into lake. One 8lb pike. He must enjoy those little 1lb walleye

Star Star Star Star Star

by MT on Mar. 25, 2018

Fishing was slow, some flood water on the lake.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Ripsomelip on Feb. 3, 2017

Has anyone been out this winter? Just curious how the fishing has been.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Desj on Jun. 21, 2016

Was out on a Saturday, lots of boats out on the lake and campground was packed. SRD checking anglers throughout morning so that was good. Not a lot of action but managed our limit of 3 each, no monster walleye but good enough for the frying pan.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Newsaskfisher on Jun. 5, 2016

Was out may long weekend... Got some walleye and pike. Really like this lake it's beautiful!

Star Star Star Star Star

by Auxjack on Mar. 5, 2016

Thanks been trying to find a decent walleye lake around

Star Star Star Star Star

by makwa1984 on Mar. 5, 2016

Sorry for being so late Auxjack , but when I was out there we didn't catch much , could see them on camera , just couldnt get them to bite , drilled a lot of holes , so thinking spot I was at isn't the hot spot for ice fishing , but we saw a few walleye ,few perch and did catch few small pike ,

Star Star Star Star Star

by Auxjack on Feb. 18, 2016

What were u catching

Star Star Star Star Star

by iFish Guest on Feb. 18, 2016

What were u catching

Star Star Star Star Star

by makwa1984 on Feb. 16, 2016

Well you weren't kidding about the snow on the lake , bye far most snow I seen this winter was on it, but all in all for first time ice fishing it , we found the fish , although they weren't very hungry , but hope to try it one more time before ice leaves ,

Star Star Star Star Star Star

by Turbofish on Jan. 31, 2016

Ice Report: 20 in
Ice is good, deep snow so need 4x4

Star Star Star Star Star

by makwa1984 on Jan. 30, 2016

Anyone ever ice fish on mistohay ?, this is one lake I don't think I ever ice fished on , fished it lots in summer ,

Star Star Star Star Star

by DaHammer on Jun. 12, 2014

Walleye are definitely biting fast. Lots is smaller ones mixed in with some 2-3lb walleye. The jacks as per usuall are everywhere as well.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Avrana on Jun. 9, 2014

Caught our limits of walleye plus. Even the pike were hitting. Only out for 3 hours to boot. ♡ this lake!

Star Star Star Star Star

by Lofirehold on May. 20, 2014

Still ice on the lake over May long weekend.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Toontowner on Aug. 13, 2013

20 pike along the south shore. 10 to15 feet of water. Used a chartreuse green crank bait and trolled. Lots of small pike but a fre in the 4 lb range. Fun day

Star Star Star Star Star

by Skstubblejumper on Aug. 7, 2013

Aug Long Weekend- Very few walleye, ones we caught were 1 lb or less, Pike were less than 3lbs and very few. Everything went back in to grow for another season. Best fishing along south side from 2nd and 3rd points in 15 ft of water.

Star Star Star Star Star

by Woody on Jul. 10, 2012

Poor fishing as it was very hot (+34), walleye turned on in the evening casting a ratlin rap towards the lilly pads on the far side of the lake across from the boat launch

Star Star Star Star Star

by Dave S. on Jun. 1, 2011

Very beautiful and good fishing. It has lots of little inlets that make real good calm fishing spots.

Add your own Feedback!

Search for a New Lake